top of page
  • PSYCHEDFORTORAH

START WITH WHY (INTRO TO AVOT)

Updated: Nov 10, 2022




"All of the Israel, have a share in the World-to-Come, as it is stated: 'And your people also shall be all righteous, they shall inherit the land forever; the branch of My planting, the work of My hands, for My name to be glorified' (Isaiah 60:21)."


“Very few people or companies can clearly articulate WHY they do WHAT they do,” Simon Sinek writes in his bestselling book, Start with Why: How Great Leaders Inspire Everyone to Action. Unfortunately, it is too easy to just go through the motions, traversing life without knowing our purpose, cause, and what drives us to get out of bed every morning. The greatest companies and leaders clearly articulate their WHY and that informs WHAT they do and HOW they follow through. As Sinek describes through examples such as Martin Luther King, Jr., Apple, and Southwest Airlines, starting with WHY is the best recipe for success, as it boosts passion, motivation, and inspires others to follow.


Writing in the 16th century, Rabbi Moshe Almosnino, begins his Pirkei Avot commentary, Pirkei Moshe, with his own suggestion as to why starting with WHY is important. Addressing why there is a custom to proclaim, “All Israel have a portion in the world to come” before learning Pirkei Avot, he writes:


Every act that a person does should be preceded by an awareness of the purpose of that act… for otherwise it will likely be unsuccessful. More so, if one wants to influence his friend in a certain direction, if he does not first explain the purpose of following in that path, the friend will not follow with happiness and goodness of heart, but will be anxious and downhearted, not knowing the purpose of the actions.


Thus, according to Rabbi Almosnino, “All Israel have a portion in the world to come” serves as a motivational framing technique, reminding the reader the WHY of Pirkei Avot—i.e., to provide spiritual and ethical guidance to prepare the reader for eternal life in the World to Come.


Abarbanel articulates the WHY of Pirkei Avot slightly differently in his commentary, Nachalat Avot, with more of an emphasis on the benefits learning Pirkei Avot can have even in this world. He writes that “all of the commentaries agree” that the purpose of Pirkei Avot is to “teach the praiseworthy character traits a person should acquire, in order that he interacts effectively with himself, his household, his state, and his nation.” The commentaries differ, in his view, concerning the source of these ethical and moral teachings. Some, like Rambam, understand the advice in Pirkei Avot to be primarily rooted in logic and empirical investigation. Consequently, there is overlap between the ethics of Pirkei Avot and the philosophical and psychological ideas found within the works of Aristotle and Plato. Others emphasize that the teachings contained within Pirkei Avot are firmly rooted in tradition, making explicit connections to the Divinely-inspired wisdom found in Tehillim, Mishlei, and other books of the Torah.


This new series, Psyched for Avot, will combine the two approaches outlined in Abarbanel. We will explore themes within Pirkei Avot, analyzing them both through a traditional lens rooted in Torah commentaries and through the empirical investigations from the field of modern psychology. Our WHY of Psyched for Avot is to converge the traditional wisdom of Pirkei Avot with the best practices of modern psychology to help us flourish in this world and the next. The analysis presented from each Mishna will help we will explore topics that will aim to increase our self-awareness, help us manage our emotions and behaviors, understand and relate better to others, learn more effectively, increase our productivity, and develop a better connection to God.


I am looking forward to taking this journey through Pirkei Avot with you!

2 comentarios


micha
07 nov 2022

More a difficulty with the beginning of Mesilas Yesharim than your presentation of the idea here, but... Do we really want our life's purpose to be "what's in it for me"? Isn't living this life for the sake of a better experience in the World to Come something lesser than partnering with the Almighty to implement the Divine Will? I am thinking of the idioms על מנת שלא לקבל פרס (Antignos ish Socho, Avos 1:3), or Rav Dessler's כח הנטילה (from his Qunterus haChessed, Michtav MeiEliyahu vol 1, pp 32-51, 140-145), or R Wolbe's derogatory definition of "frumkeit" as an instinct and thus self-serving, as a contrast to avodas Hashem (Alei Shur vol II pp. 152-155). There is strong logic and strong precedent…


Me gusta
psychedfortorah
psychedfortorah
09 nov 2022
Contestando a

Thank you Micha for your question - I definitely believe that there is a strong strand in Pirkei Avot and its commentaries that argue that there is a benefit for you personally in this world and the next world for following the messages (and it isn't something that Ramchal made up in the 18th century). I think that message can be tracked back to straight pesukim in the Torah, and has strong backing in Mishlei and related works. As you are aware from your work on Sharei Yosher, it is hard to ignore the importance of the self at least as a starting point of motivation. I don't see this as selfish (although theoretically it can be), nor as negating…

Me gusta
bottom of page